Month: December 2016

(Subscribers click here to view this article in the members area.)

Maps by Evan Centanni, from base map by Vascer (CC BY-SA)

By Bryn Jansson
 

Wallonia vs. the European Union

Belgium often seems like an afterthought in European politics. It doesn’t have the economic clout of a Germany, the political influence of a France, or the military power of a Britain. It’s a small country tucked into the northwest corner of Europe, and known mostly for its chocolate and beer (though the acclaim both have earned is well-deserved). It’s home to the European Union headquarters in Brussels, but otherwise holds no special political power in the for-now 28-nation bloc.

Yet there it was this October, caught in the middle of a European political drama, the lone holdout of the EU-28 against the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), a large scale free-trade deal with Canada. Even more amazingly, it wasn’t even the whole of Belgium blocking the trade deal, but only the sub-region of Wallonia, home to 32 percent of Belgians (known as “Walloons”) and less than 1 percent of EU citizens.

So how did a region accounting for only about 10 percent of Belgian exports to Canada find itself with the power to thwart the EU and its own national government on CETA? In a nutshell, the answer lies in an unusually complex domestic political scene that has, over the past 45 years, devolved so much power to sub-national governments that the federal government must get approval from each of the constituent parts before making a trade agreement, as well as some other types of international deals. How Belgium got here is, as you might expect, a long story.

Country Short Name:   • Belgium (English)  • België (Dutch/Flemish) • Belgique (French) • Belgien (German) Full Official Name:   • Kingdom of Belgium (English) • Koninkrijk België (Dutch/Flemish) • Royaume de Belgique (French) • Königreich Belgien (German)  Capital: Brussels

How Belgium Works

Most modern federal countries are made up of non-overlapping sub-national territories: think American states, German Länder or even Australian states and territories. But Belgium, in its own special way, set up its federation to include two overlapping but closely related sets of territories. There are the three “regions” – the Flemish Region (a.k.a. “Flanders”) in the north, the Walloon Region (Wallonia) in the south, and the capital territory of Brussels, an enclave surrounded by southern Flanders – which are the closest thing to the traditional states or provinces we’re used to. These regions have power over things like the economy, transportation, and territorial planning.

Laid over that map, there are three language-based “Communities”: the Flemish Community, the French Community, and the German-speaking Community. The Flemish Community (Flemish being the Belgian variety of Dutch) includes all of Flanders, and the French Community includes most of Wallonia, with Brussels shared between the two. Meanwhile, the German-speaking Community lies within Wallonia, along Belgium’s eastern border with Germany. The Communities have control over things like culture, education, and language matters. Both the Flemish and French Communities share influence over Community-level issues in bilingual Brussels.

Territory Name  • Wallonia (English)  • Wallonie (French) • Wallonie/Wallonien (German) Full Official Name:   • Walloon Region (English) • Région wallonne (French) • Wallonische Region (German)  Capital: Namur Status: Federal Region of Belgium

Each of the regions and communities has its own Council (Parliament) and government (executive branch), though the Flemish Region and language community long ago merged their councils and parliaments, leaving five federal entities in total. The Belgian system requires all five governments to approve any trade deal before the federal government can give its assent. In CETA’s case, Flanders, the German-speaking Community, and the federal government were all in favor, but the Walloon region and the French Community (remember, largely the same territory), plus Brussels, hesitated. With no coercive powers, all Belgium and the EU could do was negotiate with the holdouts.

Now, who would ever purposely choose to design a system this convoluted? If you answered “Belgians,” you’d be right, but even they didn’t go straight there. Belgium’s system came about through a long and complex, but fascinating, history.

How Did Belgium Get This Way?

Modern Belgium became a country in 1830, when the largely Catholic southern half of the United Kingdom of the Netherlands broke away from the politically dominant Protestant-majority northern half, creating the Kingdom of Belgium. While religiosity is now down in Belgium (as it is all over Europe), the Catholic Church is still largely seen as a unifying force there.

Although Belgium is a country united, at least historically, by religion, it’s also strongly divided by language. As described above, it has three official languages (Dutch/Flemish, French, and German), though French has long been politically dominant. This language divide has historically been a sore spot for many Flemings, as political power was controlled by French-speaking elites, and for much of Belgium’s early history, French was the only language of official business. For a time it was illegal for courts and schools to use Flemish, while even the Flemish upper classes generally spoke French and looked down on Flemish-speakers. Even today, after years of officially bilingual policy, most Walloons speak no Dutch, while most Flemings speak at least some French.*

The economy has always been unbalanced in Belgium, too. Wallonia was the first region in continental Europe to industrialize in the early 19th century, and it continued to be a powerhouse of heavy industry until the end of the post-World War II economic boom in Western Europe. As the aged industrial infrastructure surviving the war deteriorated, coal mines began to dry up, and previously wealthy Wallonia slipped into economic decline.*

Meanwhile, as Wallonia was first taking off industrially, Flanders remained more agricultural. With the best coal mines and steel plants farther south, Flanders stayed significantly poorer than its French-speaking neighbor until a boom hit in the 1960s. Largely because it wasn’t tied to a dying heavy industry sector, Flanders was able to more easily develop a vibrant light industry and service economy.*

As a result, Flanders was no longer the economic laggard, and began demanding the political power to accommodate the shift. Beginning in 1970, a series of constitutional reforms began the process of decentralizing political power. The first move, in 1970, was the creation of the language communities, followed by the regions in 1980. Further powers were devolved over the course of the 1980s, and in 1993 the Belgian constitution was amended to fully reflect the federal structure. Tweaks in 2001 – including the devolution of economic (and thus trade) policy to the regions – and 2012 have sorted out further conflicts. Ironically, it was the Flemings who pushed for devolution of trade powers – a move that later allowed Wallonia to block the Flanders-supported trade deal.

This series of constitutional reforms reflected a struggle to keep Wallonia from having too much control over Flanders or vice versa. But the strengthening of the regional governments has taken a toll on national politics. Belgium takes an average of 98 days to form a parliamentary government after an election, the longest of any democracy in Europe. It also holds the world record for longest period without an elected government in a democracy – a whopping 541 days in 2010-2011.

It’s this weak federal government role that gave little Wallonia the power to block the massive trade deal with Canada, after the EU decided to pursue an ambitious type of arrangement that required the approval of all 28 member countries. Most EU countries have kept that power contained at the national level, where there’s a greater consensus for free trade. But the decentralized Belgian system gave Wallonia a voice that allowed it to rise above the Belgian reputation for beer, chocolate, and Brussels – at least until a few tweaks to the treaty satisfied the Walloon government, and it allowed the EU and Canada to finally sign CETA on October 30.

*Source: Judt, Tony. Postwar: A History of Europe Since 1945

Graphics of the Belgian flag and the Walloon flag are in the public domain.